1 Thing A Week 1 Thing
A Week

An update on my linked data experiment TL;DR: It's not going to plan!

Week 151.0 — 14th September '20

A few weeks ago I launched a linked data experiment, I wanted to see if I could get Google to display some helpful information just by using linked data and the definitions from schema.org.

It's been around 3 months since I launched the experiment and I initially had some success. Google would show opening times for various days of the week, but not all. I'm not sure what the logic was, but it wouldn't show the results for Monday to Wednesday.

Google mobile search results

This screenshot was taken on a Monday (6th July) so it would have been more useful to have had the current and upcoming days.

I investigated some more and made a bunch of changes based on validation from Google's own SEO tools and I realised I'd made mistakes with the schema in general. All fixed, but now there's no highlighted information. It is then top result when I run a specific search but that's not quite the goal I had in mind.

A small victory

Both DuckDuckGo and Google failed to render the information I was expecting, but surprisingly (to me) Bing was the one search engine that did something useful.

Bing mobile search results

On mobile, you get options that let you start a call or to find directions. And they work!

(I have no idea why blog.charanj.it has been selected as the domain!)

Bing desktop search results

On desktop you get the phone number and address but neither are clickable. You also get the opening times for each day which is exactly what I'd have expected from Google.

What's next?

This experiment was driven by a project I've been thinking about for about 10 years now. Having shipped SITEJOY, I wanted to finally make some progress with the oldest idea I've had and this was the first step to actually realising it. It's a big setback but with more research I'm hoping I can revisit it next year and come back with a plan to make it happen.

I'll be removing the page from the sitemap, and adding a `noindex` flag on it so if you do search for 'maloha newsagents opening times', you're unlikely to find the right result.

More from 1 Thing A Week
« Apple delays iOS 14's anti-tracking features until 2021 Apple's iPhone 11, iPhone 11 Pro & Apple Watch Series 5 Making better use of Twitter threads »

Advertisement

Notable

Quick links and commentary on interesting articles, videos and more throughout the week.

  1. 151.1 – Monday
    1. The Loftie Clock   $129 byloftie.com
    2. Comedy Wildlife Photography awards 2020 finalists theguardian.com
    3. How Big Oil misled the public into believing plastic would be recycled Laura Sullivan on text.npr.org
    4. "Save Yourselves!" trailer Bleecker Street on youtube.com
    5. Solar Roof Tiles - should every building generate its own power? fullychargedshow on youtube.com
  2. 151.2 – Tuesday
    1. "Sneakerheads" trailer Netflix on youtube.com
    2. "The Trial of The Chicago 7" trailer @netflix on twitter.com
  3. 151.3 – Wednesday
    1. The new iPad Air is compatible with the Apple Pencil 2 @cchana on twitter.com
  4. 151.4 – Thursday
    1. iLy-Ai wooden electric scooter gessato.com
    2. Drowning in plastic graphics.reuters.com
    3. When you browse Instagram and find former Australian Prime Minister Tony Abbott's passport number mango.pdf.zone
  5. 151.6 – Saturday
    1. "LOVE AND MONSTERS" trailer Paramount Pictures on youtube.com

Jump to notable items for Week #150, Week #152 , view the notable archive or my favourites.

About 1 Thing A Week

A website curated by @cchana bringing you 1 Thing A Week, delivered every Monday morning.

You can find a list of all articles in the archive, or read the most popular.

Find out more about 1 Thing A Week or read the privacy policy.

Market

Visit the market and support 1 Thing A Week.

You can find 1 Thing A Week on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram & Reddit

Basic Analytics